History Challenge & Journal
- pharvey
- Moderator
- Posts: 15851
- Joined: Sat Aug 29, 2009 10:21 am
- Location: Sir Fynwy - God's Country
Re: History Challenge
OK...... What is this, who plays for it and where and when did it originate?
"Hope is a good thing, maybe the best of things" - Yma o Hyd.
Re: History Challenge
'Tis the Calcutta Cup awarded to the winner of the annual rugby union Six Nations competition.
Named such as the competition originated in Calcutta in 1872.
Pete 
Named such as the competition originated in Calcutta in 1872.


Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed. Source
- pharvey
- Moderator
- Posts: 15851
- Joined: Sat Aug 29, 2009 10:21 am
- Location: Sir Fynwy - God's Country
Re: History Challenge
Correct on the cup, but a Gnat's hair away from the restprcscct wrote:'Tis the Calcutta Cup awarded to the winner of the annual rugby union Six Nations competition.
Named such as the competition originated in Calcutta in 1872.Pete

"Hope is a good thing, maybe the best of things" - Yma o Hyd.
- barrys
- Legend
- Posts: 2296
- Joined: Fri Sep 23, 2005 1:52 pm
- Location: Enjoying the sea air on a boat around Pak Nam Pran
Re: History Challenge
I though it was awarded to the winner of the Scotland - England match during the 6 nations tournamentprcscct wrote:'Tis the Calcutta Cup awarded to the winner of the annual rugby union Six Nations competition ...

- pharvey
- Moderator
- Posts: 15851
- Joined: Sat Aug 29, 2009 10:21 am
- Location: Sir Fynwy - God's Country
Re: History Challenge
It is indeed....barrys wrote:I though it was awarded to the winner of the Scotland - England match during the 6 nations tournamentprcscct wrote:'Tis the Calcutta Cup awarded to the winner of the annual rugby union Six Nations competition ...


"Hope is a good thing, maybe the best of things" - Yma o Hyd.
- sandman67
- Rock Star
- Posts: 4398
- Joined: Wed Jul 11, 2007 6:11 pm
- Location: I thought you had the map?
Re: History Challenge
OK....this one stalled in takeoff so Ill give you the man in photo 1
that is Fritz Otto Bernert
as Jimbob correctly spotted from Bader and Richthoven the answer to Q2 is that they are all Fighter Aces.
Now .... on to the last question. Who is the odd man out and why.
I can think of at least 5 reasons for one or the other to be the odd man out, so the glazed donut goes to the person to get the most correct possible answers.
chocks away chaps

that is Fritz Otto Bernert
as Jimbob correctly spotted from Bader and Richthoven the answer to Q2 is that they are all Fighter Aces.
Now .... on to the last question. Who is the odd man out and why.
I can think of at least 5 reasons for one or the other to be the odd man out, so the glazed donut goes to the person to get the most correct possible answers.
chocks away chaps



"Science flew men to the moon. Religion flew men into buildings."
"To sin by silence makes cowards of men."
"To sin by silence makes cowards of men."
Re: History Challenge
[quote="Arcadian]
OK Siani, they are the nationalities of the UN General Secretaries since it was formed.[/quote]
Damn, I was nearly there!
OK Siani, they are the nationalities of the UN General Secretaries since it was formed.[/quote]
Damn, I was nearly there!

Re: History Challenge
I would say pewter. When I first looked at it I thought Thailand, Burma, Laos, Cambodia, India. But....it looks old and those first 4 did have organized, trophy presenting activities in those primitive days to my knowledge. Second clue it was India was the blanket on the elephant which looks different than that used on SEA changs. Petepharvey wrote:Correct on the cup, but a Gnat's hair away from the restprcscct wrote:'Tis the Calcutta Cup awarded to the winner of the annual rugby union Six Nations competition.
Named such as the competition originated in Calcutta in 1872.Pete
...... good on the year also. As a bonus, what is it made from?

Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed. Source
Re: History Challenge
OK Red Leader
We are talking about disabiities!
Fritz Otto Bernert had the use really of one arm
Bader had his legs problems
both survived crashes only to die of 'natural causes.
We salute the brave who go so far for their countries
We are talking about disabiities!
Fritz Otto Bernert had the use really of one arm
Bader had his legs problems
both survived crashes only to die of 'natural causes.
We salute the brave who go so far for their countries
Re: History Challenge
Correct on the cup, but a Gnat's hair away from the rest
...... good on the year also. As a bonus, what is it made from?[/quote]
The Calcutta Cup is made from melted down silver rupees. This money was what was left of the funds of the Calcutta Rugby Club when it was disbanded in 1878. The club had been formed in 1873, but lack of players hastened it's demise. The 'Calcutta' Cup was presented to the RFU to be presented to the winner of the annual England/Scotland match, as the original club had been born out of a match organised between 20 Englismen and 20 Scots, Irishmen and Welshmen on Christmas Day 1872.
A beautiful trophy!

The Calcutta Cup is made from melted down silver rupees. This money was what was left of the funds of the Calcutta Rugby Club when it was disbanded in 1878. The club had been formed in 1873, but lack of players hastened it's demise. The 'Calcutta' Cup was presented to the RFU to be presented to the winner of the annual England/Scotland match, as the original club had been born out of a match organised between 20 Englismen and 20 Scots, Irishmen and Welshmen on Christmas Day 1872.
A beautiful trophy!
- pharvey
- Moderator
- Posts: 15851
- Joined: Sat Aug 29, 2009 10:21 am
- Location: Sir Fynwy - God's Country
Re: History Challenge
The Calcutta Cup is made from melted down silver rupees. This money was what was left of the funds of the Calcutta Rugby Club when it was disbanded in 1878. The club had been formed in 1873, but lack of players hastened it's demise. The 'Calcutta' Cup was presented to the RFU to be presented to the winner of the annual England/Scotland match, as the original club had been born out of a match organised between 20 Englismen and 20 Scots, Irishmen and Welshmen on Christmas Day 1872.Siani wrote:Correct on the cup, but a Gnat's hair away from the rest...... good on the year also. As a bonus, what is it made from?
A beautiful trophy![/quote]
Go to the top of the class young lady!!


"Hope is a good thing, maybe the best of things" - Yma o Hyd.
Re: History Challenge
Damn, I was nearly there!Jimbob wrote:[quote="Arcadian]
OK Siani, they are the nationalities of the UN General Secretaries since it was formed.

just for the record the next head honchos were and are:
Javier Pérez de Cuéllar Pérez de Cuéllar, Javier, 1920–, Peruvian diplomat, secretary-general of the United Nations (1982–92).
Boutros Boutros-Ghali Boutros-Ghali, Boutros , 1922–, ..... Click the link for more information. Egyptian 1992–96
Kofi Annan Annan, Kofi Atta 1938–, Ghanaian diplomat, secretary-general of the United Nations (1997–2006),
Ban Ki-Moon Ban Ki-Moon , 1944–, South Korean diplomat, secretary-general of the United Nations (2007–),
Re: History Challenge
A little light hearted quiz
these three women share something in common
what is it, and who were they. (subject promoted by another thread)
these three women share something in common
what is it, and who were they. (subject promoted by another thread)
Re: History Challenge
Well I know 1 is Lily Langtry coz it says so in the pic
I'm guessing they all had relationships with English kings?


I'm guessing they all had relationships with English kings?
- sandman67
- Rock Star
- Posts: 4398
- Joined: Wed Jul 11, 2007 6:11 pm
- Location: I thought you had the map?
Re: History Challenge
Ok...looks like Jimbob wins the tasty choccy glazed donut challenge....
Heres the list of possible odd man out answers I came up with
Bader is the odd man out because hes ENGLISH.... the other two are Germans....obvious see
Bader is the odd man out because hes a WW2 pilot and the other two are WW1...again pretty obvious
Richthoven is the odd man out because hes the only whole man there...Bader had no legs and
Bernert had no left arm (see its tucked behind his back in the photo?)
Richthoven is the odd man out because hes the one that died in combat - Bader and Bernert died after leaving the forces.
Bader is the odd man out because he was the only one to be shot down and taken prisoner. Both
Richthoven and Bernert survived multiple shootings down but were never taken prisoner.
Bernert is the odd man out because he was the only one to fly wearing glasses. (disabled and short sighted...phew!)
Bernert is the odd man out as although all three were classed as flying aces, only Bernert achieved the "Ace in a Day" status (5 kills in one mission... he actually did it in one 20 minute dog fight) .
so...glazed donut to Jimbob and the bill for coffee to the rest.

Heres the list of possible odd man out answers I came up with
Bader is the odd man out because hes ENGLISH.... the other two are Germans....obvious see
Bader is the odd man out because hes a WW2 pilot and the other two are WW1...again pretty obvious
Richthoven is the odd man out because hes the only whole man there...Bader had no legs and
Bernert had no left arm (see its tucked behind his back in the photo?)
Richthoven is the odd man out because hes the one that died in combat - Bader and Bernert died after leaving the forces.
Bader is the odd man out because he was the only one to be shot down and taken prisoner. Both
Richthoven and Bernert survived multiple shootings down but were never taken prisoner.
Bernert is the odd man out because he was the only one to fly wearing glasses. (disabled and short sighted...phew!)
Bernert is the odd man out as although all three were classed as flying aces, only Bernert achieved the "Ace in a Day" status (5 kills in one mission... he actually did it in one 20 minute dog fight) .
so...glazed donut to Jimbob and the bill for coffee to the rest.



"Science flew men to the moon. Religion flew men into buildings."
"To sin by silence makes cowards of men."
"To sin by silence makes cowards of men."