Id always advocate the Andaman Club crossing option as its just plain easier than dealing with all the lunacy at both ends of the Victoria Point crossing. You also dont get soaking wet when theres a monsoon squall.
I did the Andaman a few weeks back and it was business as usual, but that was a few days before the reported floods.
The lass on the desk said they had cancelled one crossing because the sea was so choppy...but that seems to be a rarity.
Id try them first mate

"Science flew men to the moon. Religion flew men into buildings."
"To sin by silence makes cowards of men."